Florida Keys specifics · Metal Is the Default
Everywhere Else Metal Is the Upsell. Here It Is the Starting Point.
In most of Florida a roofer works up from shingle to metal and metal is the premium option. In the Keys that ordering is reversed, and shingle is the specification that ought to arrive with an explanation.
Give us the mile marker, tell us what is on the roof now, and say whether the property is rented out. Those three shape the job.
Metal
Down here it is the normal answer, not the upsell
Load path
At these wind speeds the covering is not the real question
Out too
The old roof has to travel the whole chain to leave
Licensed
A licensed Florida general contractor
A recommendation formed a hundred miles away
Many of the crews quoting in this county are based on the mainland and specify what their suppliers stock and their estimators price every day. That is shingle. Nothing dishonest is happening — the product is legitimate, correctly rated versions exist, and the contractor genuinely believes it is a fine answer, because where they work it usually is. What is missing is that nobody in the conversation priced the option that suits these conditions best.
Why the ordering flips down here
- Uplift resistance, at the highest design pressures in the state.
- Continuous salt exposure with no sheltered part of the county.
- Dead load, which matters on elevated and older structures.
- Service life, against the cost of doing this again sooner.
- How long you actually intend to hold the property.
What the existing roofscape tells you
Look along almost any street in this county and the proportion of metal is markedly higher than on the mainland. That is not fashion. It is a long accumulation of owners and builders responding to the same wind and the same salt.
It is a reasonable prompt for a homeowner: if metal is this common here and it was not on your quote, the useful question is simply why not, and the answer will tell you something about whose job it was to raise it.
How we handle it
- 01Price metal as a matter of course, not on request.
- 02Put shingle beside it so the comparison is on numbers.
- 03Explain what each system asks of you afterwards.
- 04Recommend shingle where it genuinely is the better fit.
This is not an argument that shingle is wrong here. It is an argument that it should be a decision. If you are selling in three years, or matching an existing building, or working to a hard budget, shingle can be exactly right. What should not happen is that metal was never mentioned because the estimator does not sell much of it.
Said plainly
Where we stop
Metal costs more up front and it is not maintenance free. On a short holding period the arithmetic often favors shingle. We would rather show you both sets of numbers than push you toward the bigger invoice.
FAQ
Common questions
- Is my contractor wrong to propose shingle?
- Not necessarily, and it is worth asking whether metal was priced and, if not, why. The answer distinguishes a considered recommendation from a default carried down from the mainland.
- How much more does metal cost?
- Meaningfully more up front and it varies with system and building. The comparison worth making is total cost over how long you intend to keep the property, not the two headline numbers.
- Does metal help with insurance?
- Carriers price from wind mitigation features rather than from the covering material as such, and what they do with that varies between carriers. We make no promises about premiums — that is a conversation for your agent.
Roofs we work on
Metal Roofs
Metal leads this list because in Monroe County it is the ordinary choice rather than the expensive one. What separates a twenty-five year metal roof from a twelve year one is almost never the panel.
Read more →
Flat & Low Slope
A great deal of Keys building stock is concrete with a flat or very low slope roof. Those roofs fail at drainage and at edges rather than across the field, and coating is the answer offered far more often than it is the right one.
Read more →
Tile Roofs
Tile appears throughout the Keys and it asks more of a building here than it does further north. Fastening is the whole conversation, and the underlayment beneath decides when the roof needs doing.
Read more →
Shingle Roofs
Shingle exists throughout the Keys and it works when it is chosen and installed deliberately. In the county with Florida's highest design wind speeds, it is the specification that ought to be explained rather than assumed.
Read more →
Leak Diagnosis
Water enters at one point and appears somewhere else. On the concrete and parapet buildings common here it can travel a long way inside a wall before anybody sees anything.
Read more →
Deck, Fastening & Uplift
The covering takes the sun and the rain. The fastening underneath is what keeps the roof on the building, and in the county with the highest design pressures in Florida that is where the job is won or lost.
Read more →
More florida keys specifics
The Load Path
Monroe County carries the highest design wind speeds in Florida. What decides how a roof performs is not principally the material on top — it is whether the whole assembly stays connected to the building.
Read more →
Tear-Off Has to Leave
Roofing is the heaviest trade in construction. A re-roof brings tons of material in and sends tons of tear-off out, and on an island chain the outbound leg is a genuine cost rather than a short trip.
Read more →
Roofs Over Rentals
A large share of Keys property is rented out. On an earning building a roofing job is scheduled around a booking calendar, and a leak is a refund and a review rather than an inconvenience.
Read more →
Next step
Find out what is actually wrong with it.
An inspection, photographs of what we found, and a written scope. If the honest answer is that it can wait another season, that is the answer you will get.